
Charlotte, NC, may get a judge to toss the wrongful-death suit over the horrific 2025 murder of Iryna Zarutska on a light-rail train, but the news that continues to break about the case leaves no question of the city’s moral guilt, even as the state seems poised to forget what lessons it did take from this nightmare.
The city is arguing that the serial public-safety failures that enabled career criminal DeCarlos Brown’s slaughter of the Ukrainian refugee fall under the cover of government immunity — that is, that it can’t be held liable for official acts such as setting its overall transit-policing strategy, and specifically its use of private-security contractors, not actual cops, to patrol the light rail.
Yet Charlotte admits 1) that Brown managed to board the train with no ticket, and 2) that there was no private-security guard in that train to stop him from stabbing Zarutska in her neck, leaving her to bleed out in a car full of frozen fellow passengers.
And the system failures go much farther than that.
Brown was a violent thug with a mile-long rap sheet, arrested and released at least 14 times over a decade-plus for crimes like assault, felony robbery and firearms possession.
Many of them took place in Mecklenburg County, where the lefty MacArthur Foundation had spent big bucks “to continue safely reducing the jail population.”
Fourteen chances to save Iryna’s life, all wasted by a blue-city “justice” system bent on maximum leniency for violent criminals.
If that doesn’t justify a wrongful death suit, it’s hard to imagine what might.
More: Brown’s documented history of mental illness left him a ticking time bomb with his schizophrenia ignored — at least until after Iryna bled out at his hands.
Indeed, then-Charlotte Mayor Vi Lyles’ initial response to the crime devoted a single sentence to Iryna (not even by name), spending far more words on sympathy for her killer because of a vague mental-health “crisis.”
The state later used Brown’s insanity to justify not putting him on trial on charges that could mean life in prison — a final insult to the memory of the woman he murdered.
The one small ray of light here was North Carolina’s 2025 passage of “Iryna’s Law,” restricting cashless bail and easing involuntary commitment.
But the bulk of the state’s Dem lawmakers voted no or abstained — and Democrats just won control of North Carolina’s lower house and near-parity in the upper: Expect them to roll back those reforms.
None of the judges who let Brown out over and over and over and over will be held responsible for Iryna’s murder, nor the lawmakers who made it so easy to leave him walking free, nor the local officials who left her exposed on that train.
Instead, the people of North Carolina — indeed voters across the nation — just chose to empower the party that demands such contempt for public safety.
Get ready for more horrors like the killing of Iryna Zarutska.