Convicted Oklahoma rapist Jesse Butler’s sexual assault case was dismissed in court this week – as a newly elected district attorney scolded the teen’s defense for trying to proclaim their innocence, blasting, “Nothing has made my blood boil more.”
Butler, who avoided 78 years in prison after he was convicted of raping and assaulting two high school girlfriends thanks to a sweetheart plea deal that saw his status reduced to a youthful offender, completed his probation Monday, CBS affiliate KWTV reported.
Butler, from Stillwater, was formally discharged from court supervision Tuesday at midnight as he turned 19 years old after completing 150 hours of community service. His lawyers are now working to have the case formally wiped from his record.
During the hearing, Butler’s defense team seemed to proclaim the teen’s innocence, irking lawyer Jeremiah Gregory, who was sworn in as district attorney for Oklahoma’s District 9, which encompasses Stillwater.
“Today’s hearing included disingenuous assertions from the defense regarding the defendant’s innocence, that he was the victim in this matter, and that the victim’s assertions were false,” he said.
“Nothing has made my blood boil more. I did not know this was going to be allowed, nor did the defense attorney reveal he intended to make any kind of statement. The statements made in court were inappropriate to say the least and I will not remain silent without contradicting such assertions.”
In his blistering rebuke, Gregory vowed to uphold Oklahoma’s “double jeopardy” clause – which means a person cannot be prosecuted by the state twice for the same offense after being convicted.
But he said he would submit the case for federal review.
“I cannot undo what has already been done, but I can – and will – continue to stand as a strong voice for all victims of violent crime.”
Butler’s lawyer, Derek Chance, admitted the bid to get the crime wiped from the teen’s record would be challenging, the Oklahoman reported.
Rachel Bussett, who represented the family of one of Butler’s victims, was left disappointed by the outcome – and also scolded Chance.
“He was basically saying that Butler was the victim and that he was innocent and that there was video evidence that demonstrated this ― and that’s just not the truth,” she told the Oklahoman.
She alluded to a video an officer found during the investigation which showed Butler “strangling [his victim] until unconsciousness,” which was cited in an affidavit seen by The Post.
“His attorney claims that the video shows this was consensual,” Bussett said.
“But the fact of the matter is that you cannot consent to strangulation.”
Bussett hasn’t ruled out the victims’ families pursuing civil cases against Stillwater High, the city itself, and the Butlers.
Butler was 17 when he was charged as an adult with 10 felony counts, including rape, attempted rape, sexual battery and assault involving two high school students.
He initially pleaded not guilty before striking a sweetheart deal that saw his status change to a youthful offender. He then switched his plea to no contest.
Oklahoma’s Youthful Offenders Act 1994 allows those under 18 who are charged with serious crimes – except first-degree murder – to be prosecuted as a juvenile.
Butler was sentenced to one year of rehabilitation and community service, and this sentence was branded a “complete injustice” by the family of one of his victims, while the other labeled it a “joke.”
Butler was accused of sexually assaulting one of his ex-girlfriends on Groundhog Day in 2024 – days after they had started dating, according to court docs.
The girl “yelled and told him [Butler] ‘no’ repeatedly and tried to push him off of her, but was unable to overpower him.”
He was accused of strangling the girl “to the point of unconsciousness” following another altercation that happened at a Walmart parking lot.
The girl claimed he was laughing at her when she regained consciousness – and also revealed she had to undergo surgery.
Butler was accused of assaulting his second victim in the spring and summer of 2024.
He strangled the girl to the point of “unconsciousness” while housesitting.
“She could not breathe, scratched at his arms, and tried to get away, but could not free herself,” the documents claimed.
“She described feeling coerced to comply to avoid being hurt,” the girl alleged, claiming Butler wanted to have sex every day.
